Home / Blog

Catching a Link Spam Catfish

Quality Link Builders Scam

If you work in SEO or own a website, you’ve almost certainly gotten the email. A friendly salesperson offers backlinks on “high DA” sites, sometimes on household-name publications, for a surprisingly reasonable price. Years ago, I got so many of these from outfits with names like “Quality Link Builders” and “Sea Beach Media” that I decided to play along with one to see how far it went.

The short version: it’s link spam, it violates Google’s guidelines, and in 2026 it’s even less likely to do anything for you than when I first wrote about it.

The Pitch Hasn’t Changed Much

The details shift, but the pattern is the same as it’s always been:

  • A cold email or LinkedIn message from someone with a friendly first name
  • A claim to be based in the US, UK, or Australia
  • A spreadsheet of “available” sites with authority scores
  • Prices that look like a bargain for links from major outlets
  • A promise of permanent, dofollow links

When I looked into the companies behind these pitches, the story fell apart quickly. One that looked like a large, established agency turned out to be an overseas operation with hundreds of salespeople using throwaway Gmail accounts. Another claimed to be based in London, but the emails came from India, and the salespeople used English-sounding names and stock photos to seem local.

The funniest part? Both companies had a domain rating of zero on their own websites. If they can’t build quality links for themselves, they can’t build them for you.

The Day I Caught the Catfish

I engaged with one salesperson who introduced herself on LinkedIn as Sara Winder from Australia. I suspected a scam from the first message, but I wanted to see the full playbook. I asked about her profile, which didn’t add up, and kept the conversation going until I asked for her list of domains.

The list included sites like Forbes and Entrepreneur. Anyone who has tried to earn a real link from those publications knows how hard it is. Packages ran as high as $1,700. In my experience, those links tend to get removed quickly, if they ever get published at all.

When I stopped responding, the messages kept coming. “Hello?” Then another “Hello?” a day later. Then more over the next several days, each a little pushier. That’s not how a legitimate agency follows up.

Why These Links Are Worse in 2026

Even when these vendors do deliver a link, Google has gotten much better at ignoring it.

SpamBrain neutralizes paid links

In its December 2022 link spam update, Google said SpamBrain can detect “both sites buying links, and sites used for the purpose of passing outgoing links.” Google uses it to neutralize the impact of unnatural links. So a lot of what you’d be paying for simply doesn’t count.

Google cracked down on renting out big sites

Many of these “major publication” placements are really content slipped onto a big site’s contributor or sponsored section. Google’s site reputation abuse policy, introduced in March 2024 and enforced starting that May, targets exactly this kind of third-party content placed to borrow a site’s ranking strength. In November 2024, Google made clear the policy applies even when the host site is involved in the content.

AI tools make the spam easier to send

The pitches have gotten more polished. AI writing tools mean the grammar is cleaner and the messages are more personalized. Don’t let a well-written email fool you. Look at who’s actually sending it.

How to Spot a Link Spam Catfish

Here’s my quick checklist before replying to any link offer:

  1. Check the sender. A free email address or a brand-new LinkedIn profile is a red flag.
  2. Look up their company website and check its own backlink profile in Ahrefs or Semrush.
  3. Reverse image search the profile photo. Stock photos show up fast.
  4. Ask for live examples of links they’ve built, then check whether those links still exist.
  5. Be skeptical of any guaranteed placement on a top-tier publication.
  6. Look at the sites on their list. If they publish on every topic under the sun with no real audience, that’s likely a private blog network.

Is All Guest Posting Bad?

No. Guest posting is a legitimate off-page tactic when it’s genuine. Google’s problem is with guest posts created mainly to pass ranking value, which it treats as unnatural links. Writing a helpful article for a relevant site with real readers, because you have something useful to say, is different from buying a slot on a site that sells links to anyone.

The test I use: would I still want this article published if it had no link at all? If the answer is yes because the audience matters to us, it’s probably a good opportunity.

What to Do Instead

Real link building takes research, relationships, and time. Here’s what I focus on with clients:

  • Answering journalist requests with genuine expertise
  • Creating original data or resources people want to cite
  • Building relationships with bloggers and publishers in your niche
  • Local sponsorships, partnerships, and community involvement

These also help with AI search. Tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google’s AI Mode lean on brands that are mentioned across trusted sites. An Ahrefs study of 75,000 brands found branded web mentions correlated more strongly with AI Overview visibility than backlinks. You can’t buy that kind of reputation from a cold emailer. You have to earn it.

So, What’s the Point?

SEO takes work. Purchased guest posts from link spam vendors can’t buy lasting results, and in the worst case they put your site at risk of a manual action. Businesses that keep buying these links usually end up paying twice: once for the links and again to clean them up.

Ignore the catfish, invest in real relationships, and your links will hold up over time. If you’ve already bought links from one of these vendors and you’re worried about the fallout, reach out. I’m happy to take a look.

Jeff Romero

About Jeff Romero

Jeff is an SEO, GEO and paid media consultant in Salt Lake City and the founder of Octiv Digital.

More About Jeff →

Want Help Putting This to Work?

Book a free 30-minute consultation and we will talk through your site, your campaigns and your goals.